Dental Staff, Plymouth, IN

Meet Our Team

We have dedicated, loyal team members who are committed to our patients’ long-term oral health. They are compassionate, caring, and clinically excellent. We have a youthful, energetic approach to dentistry.

Dr. Plumlee

Louis Plumlee, DDS

Dr. Plumlee graduated from the Indiana University School of Dentistry in 1985. He has invested numerous hours in continuing education. Dr. Plumlee’s goal is to stay on the cutting edge in the ever-changing science of dentistry.

His continuing education courses include:
• Hands-on cosmetic courses given by the best cosmetic dentists in the country.
• Oral surgery and endodontic classes.
• How to manage snoring and sleep apnea with dental appliances.
• Orthodontics utilizing the functional philosophy, which incorporates orthopedic appliances in conjunction with braces.

Dr. Plumlee is all about patient care, but he also has time to pursue his avid interest in golf, reading, and travel. He and his wife, Sally, have 10 grandchildren who they love to spend time with.

Dr, Corsbie

Kurt Corsbie, DDS

Dr. Corsbie grew up in Plymouth and graduated from Plymouth High School. He attended Butler University where he earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Chemistry and Biology, Magna Cum Laude. He then received his Doctor of Dental Surgery degree at the University of Michigan where he attended dental school. Dr. Corsbie is now very happy to be serving his hometown community! After dental school, he has continued to expand his knowledge as he incorporates dental implant services into the practice and continues to be a life-long learner to provide improved care to our patients.

Dr. Downey

Kevin Downey, DDS

Dr Kevin Downey grew up in Michigan City and attended Wabash College for his undergraduate degree and then graduated with his doctorate degree from Indiana University School of Dentistry in 2017. He is married and has 3 children. In his free time, he enjoys kickboxing and is an avid Chicago sports fan.


Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Rhonda has been an expanded dental assistant for 27 years and has worked for Dr. Plumlee for the past 17 years. She’s a Michigan native and when she isn’t busy making smiles brighter she spends time with her husband of 33 years, two children, and three grandchildren! She is always game for new adventures!

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Krysta has been a dental hygienist for over 12 years. She has been with Plumlee Dentistry for over 6 years, as well as teaching dental courses at IUSB. She enjoys spending time with her husband Steve and their 3 children. They enjoy numerous outdoor activities including water sports, camping, and gardening.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Jenny has been a Licensed Dental Hygienist for over 23 years. She has been back practicing with Dr. Plumlee for about 6 years. Jenny was raised and still resides in Plymouth with her husband, Corey, and their two sons. In her spare time, she loves spending time outdoors and watching sporting events with family and friends. She can be found at a basketball court or baseball field, cheering on her boys and their friends. Jenny loves the “hometown” feel of our practice and building relationships with her patients.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Lori is a dental hygienist and treatment coordinator with 20 years of experience. She has worked with Dr. Plumlee for 16 years. She lives in Plymouth. Outside of the office she enjoys spending time with her family and friends and loves being outside and gardening with her daughter.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Elaine has been with Dr. Plumlee for over 35 years. Moving here from Cincinnati will be married for 50 years and has 2 children, 7 grandchildren, and 1 great-granddaughter. She enjoys cooking, watching her grandkids play sports, and being with her Cincinnati family and friends. She is also an avid Bengals fan!

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Clare is a dental hygienist and has been with our office for over 5 years. In her free time, she says “I love cooking, baking, and hiking… My husband and I love playing board games, walking our dog, and finding any reason to throw a party!”

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Sarah has worked in dentistry for over 20 years as an expanded dental assistant. She says, “I love traveling with my best friend & husband & daughter in the Great Outdoors…I love anytime I can play outside & listen to good music with friends & family!”

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Kylie is an expanded dental assistant who has worked with Dr. Plumlee for over 7 years. Outside of the the office she enjoys spending time with family and friends.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Betty is a member of the front desk team and handles insurance needs for our patients. She has been employed in our office since November 2018. She has two adult children and two grandchildren. She and her husband, George, enjoy family time, flower gardening, fishing, and watching the wildlife that inhabits their property.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Brandi has been a dental hygienist for 11 years. Brandi’s favorite part of her job is providing patients the experience of good dental care and the feeling of a great smile. She loves getting to know her patients and building long-term relationships. She enjoys educating and encouraging patients throughout their dental journey. When Brandi isn’t working in the office she loves going on adventures with her husband, Lucas and two sons, Jaxon and Deacon. Their hobbies include camping, sports, gardening, and the outdoors.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Jennifer is one of our front desk receptionists. She has been with Dr. Plumlee for over 2 years. Jen is a lifetime resident of Plymouth with 4 children. Outside of work, she loves vacationing and spending time with family as well as attending her children’s sports events.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Katie is a front desk receptionist with over 20 years of office experience. Katie joined our team in December 2022. She currently resides in Plymouth with her husband Brad and 3 children. Katie enjoys watching and supporting her kids in all of their sports and activities.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Alison is an expanded dental assistant. She graduated from IU Fort Wayne dental assisting school. Alison is from Knox and has been working with Dr. Plumlee for almost a year. In her spare time, she enjoys farming with her boyfriend and being with her family.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Missy has been a hygienist for 5 years and started with Plumlee Dentistry in November 2022. She is a Plymouth Native and has 2 teenage boys. In her free time, she enjoys being outside, kayaking the river, relaxing near water, and live music experiences.

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Kelly is an expanded dental assistant with over 20 years of experience and has been with Dr. Plumlee for over 2 years. Outside of the office she enjoys spending time with family and friends

Dental Care, Plymouth, IN


Kacee has been an expanded dental assistant for almost 2 years. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her family, including her two fur babies, hunting, and going to the gym!

Now Accepting New Patients!